Yorks Bakery Cafe, Newhall Street

The Yorks Bakery Cafe logo: does what it says on the board.A short walk north of Birmingham’s New Street Station (its website says seven minutes, I reckon I can do it in five, even if it’s all uphill) and even closer to Snow Hill Station, Yorks Bakery Cafe has just about everything you could want: fantastic coffee from espresso machine or brew bar, including cold brew, a choice of 16 teas, a brunch menu served until four o’clock, loads of fabulous cakes…

Pause for breath…

… a wide range of seating, in three different areas, free wifi, friendly, helpful staff (who even arranged for the sun to come out for my visit).. The list goes on. If you’re not convinced by now, I’m not sure you ever will be, but just in case…

The coffee is from London roasters, Caravan, which is consistently turning out coffee I like, and Yorks is up there with the best of them when it comes to making great coffee. There’s a comprehensive range of espresso-based drinks, but the real sign of excellence is the brew bar which offers V60 pour-over or Aeropress for one and Chemex or Cafetiere to share. There’s a choice of three beans at the brew bar and a seasonal single-origin espresso bean.

February 2016: Newhall Street has now closed, the building undergoing a major refurbishment. As a result, the mantle of Yorks Bakery Cafe has passed to the new cafe/roastery on Stephenson Street, which is even closer to New Street Station.

You can read more of my thoughts after the gallery.

  • Yorks Bakery Cafe on Newhall Street, making good use of its store-front and the A-boards.
  • Yorks is clearly keen on its breakfasts. Others take note: served UNTIL 4PM!
  • That's also a pretty impressive list...
  • Key words: free wifi & (for this summer in particular) air-conditioning!
  • Okay, Yorks is serious about breakfast - this greets you on stepping through the door!
  • Turning to your right, this is the main space.
  • More of the seating in the main area.
  • Prime armchair spot by the window.
  • A sofa in the main area.
  • Caravan Coffee on the middle shelf. We'll ignore the bottom shelf, shall we?
  • An impressive array of coffee-making equipment.
  • Looks like a breakfast station to me...
  • Condiments, cutlery and water, between the front and back seating areas.
  • The mixed seating in the back. That's my stuff in the far corner.
  • More of the seating at the back.
  • Most of the tables had their own cultery and menus, which included the coffee menu.
  • There was even a small book shelf.
  • Some of the seating in the little area right at the back.
  • The little bar in the corridor wasn't very popular while I was there.
  • So, down to business: the counter looks enticing.
  • Another view of the counter
  • The espresso machine was tempting, but I decided to look elsewhere...
  • No, not there! (although it is an impressive tea menu)
  • There: the brew bar.
  • My Tanzanian Ruvuma AAA, made with an Aeropress. Delightful.
  • The cakes looked tempting too: 'get stuck in!!' hmmm... very tempting!
  • The sandwiches looked good too, but I wanted brunch.
  • Poached eggs on toast. It was that or the pancakes.
Javascript Sliders by WOWSlider.com v4.6

Yorks Bakery Cafe is somewhere I’d heard a lot about and was also recommended by a friend from Wolverhampton as the one place I had to go to when in Birmingham. These recommendations can be a double-edged sword: what to say if you really hate a place? Fortunately, I needn’t have worried: Yorks is lovely.

From the moment I stepped through the door, I was sold. It’s a big place: high ceilings, exposed air-conditioning conduits, wooden floors and plain, painted walls. The main part is neatly split in two by the counter, creating two seating areas, one out front by the counter, flooded with light from the windows; the other, behind the counter, a little darker, slightly less hectic. The lack of windows is compensated for by multiple light bulbs hanging down from the high ceiling, giving it a sense of space.

A corridor on the left-hand side connects the two areas and extends back to provide access to the toilets. Opposite these, right at the back, is a third, much smaller seating area, with a couple of tables. A bar, compete with bar stools, also runs along part of the corridor. The seating is wonderful, an equal mix of low tables with armchairs and sofas, and normal tables with surprisingly comfortable plastic bucket chairs for those who are eating.

One word of caution: Yorks is loud, not in a bad way, but it’s an echoing space and, while I was there, full of chatty people competing with the background music. If you sit out front, you have the additional noise from behind the busy counter. For me it was just the right side of oppressive, but if you have problems with background noise, you might find Yorks a little overwhelming on a busy day. That said, while I was there, the small seating area at the back was empty and very quiet.

Turning to the coffee, there were so many options that I thought I better experiment. The espresso range looked tempting, with the piccolo and flat white probably edging out the other options. However, I decided to save that for another visit, turning instead to the brew bar and the Tanzanian Ruvuma AAA. I approached this with a little trepidation since it was described as “like a delicate black tea with a sweet acidity”. I decided it was best tackled as an Aeropress and was rewarded with a surprisingly pleasant, very smooth, not too complex coffee, which was sweet, but not unpleasantly so. I’d have preferred a little more body and perhaps slightly more bite, but that’s being picky.

It being lunchtime, I skipped cake (with a plan to make up for it later in the day) and perused the brunch menu which was being served until four o’clock. I wish everyone else would take a leaf out of Yorks’ book: brunch should be served until at least two o’clock.

I chose poached eggs on toast (it was either that or pancakes; let me tell you, I was tempted) and while I enjoyed them, I found them too salty, not so much as to spoil the experience, but enough for me to notice. My only other complaint would be the relative lack of vegetarian options: an Eggs Florentine to go with the Eggs Benedict would have been nice.

http://yorksbakerycafe.co.uk +44 (0) 121 236 8090
Monday 07:30 – 21:00 Roaster Caravan (espresso + filter)
Tuesday 07:30 – 19:00 Seating Tables, Sofas, Armchairs, Bar, Table (Outside)
Wednesday 07:30 – 19:00 Food Breakfast/Brunch, Sandwiches, Cake
Thursday 07:30 – 19:00 Service Order at Counter
Friday 07:30 – 19:00 Cards Amex, Mastercard, Visa, Droplet
Saturday 08:30 – 19:00 Wifi Free
Sunday 09:30 – 19:00 Power A few
Chain No Visits 30th July 2013

You can see what my fellow blogger A Southern Belle in London made of Yorks. You can also see what I made of Yorks Cafe & Coffee Roasters, the successor the Cafe Bakery, and also what I thought of Yorks Espresso Bar, the little brother of the Yorks empire.

If you liked this Coffee Spot, then check out the rest of Birmingham’s speciality coffee scene with the Coffee Spot Guide to Birmingham.

If you liked this post, please let me know by clicking the “Like” button. If you have a WordPress account and you don’t mind everyone knowing that you liked this post, you can use the “Like this” button right at the bottom instead. [bawlu_buttons]
Don ‘t forget that you can share this post with your friends using the buttons below.

25 thoughts on “Yorks Bakery Cafe, Newhall Street

    • It is almost entirely in the wrong direction!

      Sadly, and much to my disappointment, plenty of places in the UK stop serving brunch at noon! Breakfast I can understand, but not brunch. I can’t help feeling that they’ve failed to grasp the concept…

  1. Pingback: 6/8 Kafé | Brian's Coffee Spot

    • If you know any better gallery tools, I’m open to suggestions.

      Were you reading it on a phone, tablet or computer? I rarely use my phone to view the site and only find it mildly annoying on the computer. I wonder if I should put in a second set of pictures without captions? The ideal solution would be if you could switch the captions off, but that doesn’t seem to be an option.

      I’ll have a play and see what I can do.

      Thanks for the feedback,

  2. Great post – thanks Brian!

    I absolutely *love* Yorks – one of the many great bits of Brum.

    The seasonal teas are a delight – try blueberry on a sunny day, or winter warmer in the snow!

    The staff are friendly, very knowledgeable and quick!

    My only minor moan is the lack of de-caffinated coffee, but I think that probably is not a good thing to admit to drinking on your blog?

    • Hi Jason,

      I’m glad you liked it. I actually agree with you on the decaffeinated coffee; maybe it’s something I should starting asking about and making a note of.

      I drink quite a bit of decaf and if I’m doing a few cafes in a day, it can be quite nice to have a decaf option somewhere along the way. There are also people who need to steer clear of caffeine for medical reasons.

      The two justifications for not stocking decaf I most frequently come across are:

      1) can’t find a bean they like
      2) isn’t enough demand to justify carrying an extra grinder

      The second is a business decision (although if it’s not there, there won’t be demand, so it could be chicken and egg) while the first I just don’t accept. Most of the good roasters do a very good decaf blend (or single origin bean).

      Thanks for the comment,

  3. Absence of cakeage…you did at least taste those samples, right?
    Agree on the vegetarian options being rather scant. Especially with such a predominance of eggs on the menu: makes a visit hard for an egg-averse veggie.
    Not that I mind having to take cake instead. Especially ones such as these, freshly and totally baked in-house.

  4. Pingback: The Coffee Spot is One! | Brian's Coffee Spot

  5. Pingback: 2013 Awards – Railway Stations | Brian's Coffee Spot

  6. Pingback: Brian's Coffee Spot

  7. Pingback: Coffee Spot Awards 2013: Winners | Brian's Coffee Spot

  8. Pingback: Saint Kitchen | Brian's Coffee Spot

  9. Pingback: Faculty | Brian's Coffee Spot

  10. Pingback: Yorks Espresso Bar | Brian's Coffee Spot

  11. Pingback: Yorks Bakery Café, Stephenson Street | Brian's Coffee Spot

  12. Pingback: Yorks Café & Coffee Roasters (Yorks Bakery Café Update) | Brian's Coffee Spot

  13. Pingback: Cafephilia | Brian's Coffee Spot

  14. Pingback: Yorks Coffee Roasters | Brian's Coffee Spot

  15. Pingback: Wayland’s Yard, Birmingham | Brian's Coffee Spot

  16. Pingback: Yorks Espresso Bar | Brian's Coffee Spot

  17. Pingback: Yorks Café & Coffee Roasters (Yorks Bakery Café Update) | Brian's Coffee Spot

Please let me know what you think. Guidelines for comments are in the "Posts" drop-down menu.